Cartailhac and Altamira Émile Cartailhac



a bison in altamira


when marcelino sanz de sautuola s daughter maría discovered paintings in altamira , sautuola, professor vilanova, published findings in 1880, cartailhac 1 of leaders of scientists who, facing revolutionary change in view of prehistoric man, ridiculed these paintings @ 1880 prehistorical congress in lisbon. due opinion, members of congress did not visit altamira. changed mind after several other caves prehistoric paintings had been found , visited cave breuill in 1902. apologised there maría de sautuola (her father died in 1888) , promised clear don marcelino s name (sautuola had been accused of forgery). letter 9 october 1902 says among other things: live in new world . wrote famous article, mea culpa d un sceptique in admitted wrong, emphasized importance of altamira, accused himself of holding progress of science, , harshly criticised himself doing injustice honest man , rejecting thing without investigation. today, opinions article vary. kleibl praises 1 of finest moments of prehistory , brave article, showing no fear of hurting [cartailhac s] professional credit , while lewis-williams writes about opportunist thing used calculatingly cartailhac s own benefit when position no longer tenable.








Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Weir report (2001) Rotherham child sexual exploitation scandal

Mussolini's views on antisemitism and race Benito Mussolini

Discography Gary Barden